Thursday, November 24, 2022

Thanksgiving Thoughts

As Americans celebrate Thanksgiving, many of us contemplate the blessings and the problems present in our society today. I feel that freedom is the greatest gift that Americans possess. In the State of the Union address in 1941, President Franklin D. Roosevelt defined four essential freedoms that needed protection in his day, and always. My Thanksgiving thoughts dwell on these freedoms and how they exist in our society now. 

Freedom of speech continues to have undisputed value, though recently has often been jeopardized. For example, the fight to keep books on library shelves, safe from self-righteous censors is a very active fight at the moment. In the campaign to destroy the freedom of reproductive choices, laws are also being proposed or enacted to muzzle speech by medical professionals or others helping women to exercise these rights. Freedom of speech is also much undermined by those who abuse it to spread false information: for example, over 300,000 covid victims have died because they were maliciously deterred from receiving immunizations (source). Our country needs to work on building trust, not destroying it. In my Thanksgiving thoughts are these ongoing struggles to protect freedom of speech and its benefits.

Freedom from want is an especially critical idea to think about on Thanksgiving, when many American families celebrate with a traditional meal. Unfortunately, many Americans are not free from want. For example, in my state, Michigan, 1.2 million people face hunger, including around 300,000 children (source). In some states, legislators are refusing Federal food benefits for citizens in need because these politicians view the hungry people as undeserving (source). Food banks and other social service organizations are stressed, as a large number of families are still suffering from the effects of the pandemic. The potential of global warming to destroy food security in coming times is another very complex issue, which I can't elaborate here. Whether we are among the fortunate or the needy, the freedom from hunger will continue to be essential to human well-being.

Freedom of worship and freedom from fear are the two other freedoms listed in Roosevelt’s speech. I am thankful that we enjoy them here in America. In Roosevelt's time, these freedoms were under unprecedented threat in Europe as the Holocaust was just beginning, ultimately resulting in the deaths of 10,000,000 human beings.

Today in America, while the situation is nowhere near as dire, both of these freedoms are jeopardized. We collectively experience the recurring nightmares of mass shootings in places of worship, in schools, and in many other gathering places. Freedom suffers because of hostility towards many minorities, including a return of the antisemitic conspiracy theories of the Nazi era and of the racist virulence of our own history. 

That said, Americans still are better off than minorities in many other countries, where worship isn't even officially protected at all, and where other personal freedoms are absent. So I am thankful for what we do have, and hopeful that we can, with a good will, improve the situation some day. I'm thankful for Roosevelt's leadership and many other people's efforts in the past. And I am thankful for the commitment to continued democratic voting that voters in several states established in the recent election. 

Norman Rockwell, "Home for Thanksgiving," 1945.

I think of the very dark days when Roosevelt gave his speech. The world was in the shadow of the coming war, facing Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan. There was a threat to all freedoms everywhere. He expressed a wish for a future where these freedoms would be protected, and he was aware that such protection would soon be very costly. He said: 

"That is no vision of a distant millennium. It is a definite basis for a kind of world attainable in our own time and generation. That kind of world is the very antithesis of the so-called 'new order' of tyranny which the dictators seek to create with the crash of a bomb. ...

"Freedom means the supremacy of human rights everywhere. Our support goes to those who struggle to gain those rights and keep them. Our strength is our unity of purpose."


Norman Rockwell: “The Four Freedoms”, 1943.

Thanksgiving thoughts inevitably turn to the history of the holiday, and the many fraught questions of the idealized story of friendship between “Pilgrims and Indians,” as opposed to the actual story. For an interesting viewpoint, see the op-ed  “It’s time to rethink” in the L.A. Times.

Blog post © 2022 mae sander. Images from Wikipedia.



My name is Erika. said...

The first Thanksgiving was nothing like I learned in school. Having studied some microbiology, it's interesting how smallpox, which devastated so many of the native population, actually helped the Pilgrims since they could raid the graves. Among other things they did to survive. I am loving the Norman Rockwell pieces you shared. It's hard to believe those are paintings and not photos. Enough said. Happy Thanksgiving Mae. hugs-Erika

Deb Nance at Readerbuzz said...

We will press on, Mae.

Happy Thanksgiving!

thecuecard said...

Happy Thanksgiving Mae. Many forget the Mar-a-Lago guy (can't say his name) & administration were much at fault for the deaths of those during the pandemic when he was there. so many needlessly died.
freedom of speech doesn't mean intentional disinformation!

eileeninmd said...

Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family! Take care, enjoy your day!

Iris Flavia said...

"That said..." - yes.
I think so about Germany as well.
We complain on a high level. Yet, if we do not... we need to, to make it all better.
I am actually really thankful every day for my work, great colleagues, not freezing too much (cellar unterneath, brrr), food, partner, family... good books and music, my half intact hearing, I could go on endlessly.

One wish I would have, though: Have a piece of a stuffed Turky. We really do not have this here (and we do not celebrate this day, either).

Great cards. Happy Thanksgiving to you.

Bleubeard and Elizabeth said...

Happy Thanksgiving, Mae. I was truly intrigued by the article you wrote. I also read the LA Times article where Indigenous people were treated so badly (fought, bought, and sold).

Freedom of speech from dis and misinformation, while freedom from want is always a top priority of mine. Freedom of worship makes me think of the black churches, especially in the south, where they have often been vandalized and/or set on fire. Freedom from fear hits pretty close to home (meaning today's news), as I watch reports of how the LGBTQ+ community is dealing with the news that they are no longer safe in their own space. Thanks for these thoughts as we celebrate this important holiday today.

Valerie-Jael said...

Happy Thanksgiving, Mae. Perhaps one day these freedoms will be available for all people on this planet. Valerie

DVArtist said...

Happy Thanksgiving Mae. You always write to make people think. I just deleted a long paragraph of my thoughts and it seemed to bleak for today. Have a lovely day.

Tandy | Lavender and Lime ( said...

How tragic that people have been refused Federal food benefits. I hope you had a meaningful Thanksgiving.

eileeninmd said...

Have a great day and good luck on the bird outing.
Happy weekend.

Harvee said...

So many things to be thankful for this year.

Dorothy Borders said...

I followed you here from Deb's Readerbuzz and I'm glad I found you and your very thoughtful post.

Cindy said...

Happy Thanksgiving!

Terrie said...

A thought provoking post and a little disheartening to realize how we're rushing backwards in our achievement of freedoms. Freedom from fear immediately makes me think of 2 things - all the students (& parents) who have to go to school and worry if there's going to be a shooting (gulp) and the feat of being black and driving or walking or anything and stopped by a cop or citizen who provokes them. I think they're a long way from "freedom from fear". However, I, like you, am thankful to live in America and I'll continue to work to help the country improve and reach those ideals.
Have a great reading week!
Terrie @ Bookshelf Journeys

Emily said...

I hope you had a good Thanksgiving. Certainly lots to think about in your post. In the UK we don't celebrate it here so I have been learning lots about it this week!

Have a good weekend.

Emily @ Budget Tales Book Blog
My post:

Jeanie said...

This is a beautiful and very thought-provoking post, Mae. Well said. As always.